Breakfast on a tray in the kitchen showing the results of the mocha coffee overnight oats recipe: stainless steel French press, coffee mug, bowl with oats, almond butter, whipped cream, and strawberries

Overnight Oats Recipe: Breakfast Fail

I’ve been warming up to overnight oats recipes lately. When I first started seeing this phenomenon all over the food blogosphere, I was skeptical. Except for the occasional eggs Benedict, I don’t usually fuss over breakfast because I just want to EAT! I usually make a week’s worth of granola so that I can just throw everything together every morning. Therefore, I didn’t know if I wanted to plan out breakfast on a nightly basis.

But a couple months ago, I was briefly trying a non-dairy diet and thought I would give overnight oats a go. The first recipe I tried was pretty basic: I re-purposed an old olive jar and poured in a half cup of oats, some almond milk, kefir, honey, and berries. Then, I faithfully stored the jar in the fridge and heated the contents up in a bowl the next morning before chowing down. I did that every day for about a week. It was nice, but then I determined dairy was okay, and I could go back to my trusty granola.

This page may contain affiliate links for which I receive a small commission should you decide to purchase any products.

Mocha coffee overnight oats

Then, last week @z.o.e.a.t.s posted a mocha coffee overnight oats recipe, and I had to try it stat! I’ve recently switched back to chicory tea (again) to manage my acid reflux. But right before that I was drinking decaf chicory coffee, which is a blend of decaf coffee and chicory granules (I recommend Starwest Botanicals chicory, which I use all the time). I decided to try Zoe’s recipe with this very coffee and figured it sure would be delicious. I was not wrong! Coffee is great, but chicory really kicks it up a notch.

Results of the mocha chicory coffee overnight oats recipe: A bowl contains the mocha overnight oats with almond butter, whipped cream, and strawberries all drizzled with honey.
Mocha chicory coffee overnight oats with almond butter, whipped cream, and strawberries all drizzled with honey

SIDENOTE: If you’re an SG-1 fan, the team detects the flavor of chicory in their coffee in the episode called “Urgo”:

Dr. Daniel Jackson: Wow, this coffee’s great!
Samantha Carter: I was just thinking that.
Jack O’Neill: Yeah, is that cinnamon?
Dr. Daniel Jackson: It’s, uh, it’s chicory.
Jack O’Neill: [contemplative] Hm, chicory.
[Teal’c unscrews the lid from the coffee pot and drinks the contents]
Samantha Carter: Teal’c?
[He continues to drink as everyone looks, then finishes.]
Jack O’Neill: Isn’t that hot?
Teal’c: Extremely.

Bad taste = lessons learned

Anyway, so mocha chicory coffee overnight oats are fantastic and highly recommended. That evening, though, I thought I would experiment with my recipe for granola. I thought, why not try an orange cranberry overnight oats recipe? It has to be delicious. I excitedly took a photo of my process, assuming that the next morning I could provide a gushing review of my genius …

Ingredients for the orange cranberry overnight oats recipe gathered around a jar holding the measured ingredients: dried cranberries, almond milk, kefir, orange extract, vanilla extract, cinnamon, orange, pumpkin seeds, and honey.
My ingredients for orange cranberry overnight oats. It was all so promising.

I rubbed my eyes, stumbled into the kitchen, and gingerly pulled the jar out of the fridge. After adding a dollop of almond butter and some strawberries, I dug in.

Results of the orange cranberry overnight oats recipe: bowl with the overnight oats, strawberries, and almond butter.
Orange cranberry overnight oats ready for eating …

The first taste was kinda blah. The second taste was starting to be gross. The third taste I got some cranberries on the spoon and promptly wanted to spit everything out. I trudged through a couple more bites and then gave up and set it all aside.

After trying the orange cranberry overnight oats recipe: Bowl with about one third of the oats left and two strawberries.
I just couldn’t finish and not because I was full.

So it seems that fashioning my own overnight oats recipe is not as simple as I first assumed. Here are the lessons I’ve learned:

  • Nuts get chewy and dried fruit gets mushy when they are kept soaking in almond milk all night.
  • Almond butter does NOT go with everything.
  • Oatmeal needs a bit more sweetener and flavoring to not just taste like watery oats.

Hope springs eternal

To add insult to injury, three of the strawberries were partially rotten. Although this experience has soured me toward the notion of slightly more fuss over breakfast than I’m used to, I’m not completely put off. As noted, the mocha overnight oats recipe turns out some pretty delicious results, so there must be some other inspiration out there for me.

What are your most entertaining breakfast fails? Breakfast wins? Any overnight oats recipe pointers?

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *